Thursday, January 10, 2013

The Prodigy Myth


The Prodigy Myth
January 10, 2013


It is a wonderful thing when we see early signs of a child prodigy.  We are tempted to get stars in our eyes and become hopeful of the fabulous future that lies just down the road.

If your child is a budding prodigy, that is well and good.  The awesome responsibility that now lies on your shoulders is immense.  Hang on.

However, if your child has a great desire, yet struggles occasionally, have faith. 


In our featured book – The Little Book of Talent - Daniel says this:


Early success turns out to be
a weak predictor of long-term success.

A few examples:
-Michael Jordan was cut from his high school varsity team as a sophomore

-Charles Darwin was considered slow and ordinary by teachers

-Walt Disney was fired from an early job because he lacked imagination


Dr. Carol Dweck of Stanford University says this about prodigies: 
“The praise and attention prodigies receive leads them to instinctively protect their “magical” status by taking fewer risks, which eventually slows their learning.”


If your child has some early success, find a way to nurture and guide him/her to keep pursuing the edges of his/her ability where improvement happens. 

What we have to guard against is allowing praise to swell their head; stunting growth and development. 


If your child doesn’t experience early success yet still has the drive and determination, treat their early efforts as experiments, not as verdicts.  Remember, this is a marathon, not a sprint.

I teach two students from the same family.  One started his musical interests by learning the trumpet and soon switched to the sax and piano.  The other started on the trumpet and switched to the drums and piano. 

It’s a marathon – not a sprint.


Carolyn Biggs
Steps and Skips
Tips for the Developing Musician

No comments:

Post a Comment